Back to shop ↗
THE HOLDEN COMMODORE FORUM

HOLDCOM Community

Built around the cars. Kept alive by the people.

+ Start a discussion
Holden Commodores gathered at Holdcom
Forum Home›General discussion
General discussion

xr6turbo vs hsv

Started by NASTY1 · 12 Apr 2009 · 62 replies

Preserved from CalaisTurbo (partial recovery). Original authors and dates are shown; archived members are not current Holdcom accounts. View original archive ↗

NASTY1Archived member
hey guys ive been looking around at buying a newer car one i can just get in and drive evry day with no hassels.been looking more and more into xr6 turbos and also vt-vy ss's and vx clubbys etc found lots and lots of auto xr6 turbos on carsales going cheap as and alos found an 02 monaro for 20k and a couple vx clubbys around $14,000 im not one to realy buy something unles its a good deal. whats pros and cons on xr6 turbos and vx clubys and vy ss's i cant seem to find many manual xr6 turbos in a decent colour. any personal opinions of people who have owned or been in any?not just your opinion if your a one sided man whos never been in one.
0 likes
blu magooArchived member
hey mate, my uncle was in the same position as you a couple of weeks ago. he was tossing up between a xr6t and a vz clubby. he ended up getting a clubby from my work and he hasnt looked back. xr6t's try to take him on all the time and he choppes em with out breaking a sweat. but the end of the day its your dosh, so go for a spin in all that your considering and make up YOUR own mind. hope this helps mate cheers Jake
0 likes
GArchived member
Quote: Originally Posted by blu magoo hey mate, my uncle was in the same position as you a couple of weeks ago. he was tossing up between a xr6t and a vz clubby. he ended up getting a clubby from my work and he hasnt looked back. xr6t's try to take him on all the time and he choppes em with out breaking a sweat. but the end of the day its your dosh, so go for a spin in all that your considering and make up YOUR own mind. hope this helps mate cheers Jake ahhahahahahahaha
0 likes
BTArchived member
buy mine
0 likes
Rusty-18Archived member
Quote: Originally Posted by G ahhahahahahahaha Just remember bud that he's talking pretty much stock... Unlike your XR6T which has been tickeled in the motor... This thread shall be interesting for me Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
INFLYTArchived member
You're better off getting the Holden. Cheap manual XR6 Turbo = T5 5 speed box made of glass and Chinese product's, meaning easily breakable under power.
0 likes
Rusty-18Archived member
Quote: Originally Posted by INFLYT You're better off getting the Holden. Cheap manual XR6 Turbo = T5 5 speed box made of glass and Chinese product's, meaning easily breakable under power. Good honesty... 'INFLYT' how would you rate yours compared to a hsv (vx-vz)...
0 likes
WeezyArchived member
I've been in a xr6t, i was disapointed Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
GArchived member
Quote: Originally Posted by Rusty-18 Just remember bud that he's talking pretty much stock... Unlike your XR6T which has been tickeled in the motor... This thread shall be interesting for me so what? my dad has a VZ Clubsport which has a full exhaust tune bla bla all I've done to my xr6t is cooler inejctors and cat and he has no chance in hell against me xr6t ftw. Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
WeezyArchived member
Buy an Import Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
trkwpnArchived member
yeh i think xr6 turbo ,, better of. nice orange one slapped on its ass with sunroof argh!!!
0 likes
NASTY1Archived member
Quote: Originally Posted by trkwpn yeh i think xr6 turbo ,, better of. nice orange one slapped on its ass with sunroof argh!!! yeah thats what im thinking Quote: Originally Posted by Weezy Buy an Import i would love a r33 gtr but cant aford one Quote: Originally Posted by BT buy mine havent got that much lol. but i have been looking around and theres 2 or 3 bargains out there forgot to pm you about swapin gts rims for 20s will do later this arvo if still interested Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
PROGMHArchived member
I think alot of the HSV's are way over priced for what you get. In saying that though I would prefer one over an XR6 due to the XR being plain and the HSV being more up market. You can get a VY-VZ SS for the price of a VT clubsport! You'd go the newer model any day. The only reason I wouldnt go an XR is because my dad has a BF XR6 ute and it is the worst car to drive. The interior is plain grey and there is just nothing really nice about them. Go to a car yard and take one of each for a spin and make up your own mind though... you're the one who has to live with it and enjoy it, not me!
0 likes
FRASHDArchived member
XR6 turbo's make about 180 to 190 stock (dyno tuned heaps of these things) factory injectors run out about 230-240 factory valve springs are only good for 11 psi factory intercooler is good for 220-230. any more and you are just cooking the air. Factory engine good for 320 SAFE BF or Typhoon have stronger rods and good for 350 SAFE. factory auto will support 280 then you loose gears, ( i know my R&D car just lost 2nd and 4th) factory diffs and drive shafts are made of play dow (will live if driven with love) cant run fuel tank under half if you intend on racing it or putting a fuel system on it. (fuel surge by 3rd gear if tank too low. (I know idiots will say they run higher boost and make more power on stock injectors..... I am talking SAFE TUNE and boost that doesn't pump the lifters after 1 pull on the dyno. VT I wouldnt get. VX to VY factory make about 180-195kws tune 220 to 230 tune and exhaust 240-250 intake tune exhaust 260 ish factory injectors and fuel system will support 300kw at wheels heads and cam will see 300 PD blower will see about 320-350 single turbo on 8 psi will see 380 ish on an un opened engine factory auto will support 300 I tune these cars all day, I like bang for buck. I recently purchased a WK Caprice. Each to their own.
0 likes
NASTY1Archived member
thanx guys it is interesting to see what peoples experiences are with both. it would be between vx clubby vyss or xr6t its interesting to see on carsales a few vz ss's have come down in the under $20,000 mark from what i have seen on carsales and other sites i could getinto the following from $15,000 xr6t and also vx clubby from around $17,000 but not r8 found this vx clubby $13,900 auto 120ks Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
PROGMHArchived member
Just remember though you're looking at breaking into the basement models for your money. You're going to be getting the dreggs (There are bargains to be had but just talking in general). eg: You can get an XR6T for 17k, or you can get a high km thrashed one for 14k.
0 likes
FRKVLTArchived member
Definitely get the XR6T!!! You won't look back!! Honestly. Everyone knows the are they are the next cult car along with the VLT's. If you want a XR6T definitely go the BF over BA and make sure its BF after 06/06 as it has the stronger internals and not to forget the 6 speed auto which can handle 400 rwkw factory.. btw bf valve springs dont have to be changed, another bonus...yes the ba v/springs are weak but cannot honestly go past a bf! Gl with your decision anyways...
0 likes
NASTY1Archived member
Quote: Originally Posted by PROGMH Just remember though you're looking at breaking into the basement models for your money. You're going to be getting the dreggs (There are bargains to be had but just talking in general). eg: You can get an XR6T for 17k, or you can get a high km thrashed one for 14k. i would be looking at spending $17,000 after paying out existing loan.i could sit back and wait for my ss to sell and spend $23,000 ish but in the end id rather spend 17k and sell my ss and put that $$$$ into my loan you would be suprised what prices are like i was when i searched car sales. i did notice lots and lots and lots of ba's for sale i went over 35 pages and there was still more to go lol although when i was looking for some reason i started searching hdt cars and vc-vl's up around the $20,000 and one fat torie sitting on 19 inch fr's in the end ill either get a vt vx vy or ba and have one car or ill get some old school muscle and keep my ss for a daily car who knows i still got alot of time to find something im sure when i see it it will jump out at me Some original photos have not been recovered yet.
0 likes
GArchived member
Get a BF XR6T.. I'm running 305rwkw in my BA with standard valve springs but thats just my car, dont think any other BA's have run the same power with standard valve springs. And with the BF you'll be able to run 350rkw + without having to worry about your auto blowing. If you want power at a cheaper price get the XR6T
0 likes
freEze_dKArchived member
as said above.. XR6T are cheap power.. with a hiflow K&N filter and a tune they already jump to the 230/240atw mark.. the change cat = 250/260 thats onlly 2 mods and a tune
0 likes
Sign in or create an account to reply. New members are welcome—no purchase or old CT account needed.

Who’s online

0 members and 1 guest active in the last 15 minutes

No signed-in members active right now. Guests are welcome to browse.

Visitors Today58

25,984 threads, 350,176 posts and 3,251 images saved from CT

75.9% of indexed threads saved